Monday, September 13, 2010

Chapter 2: Identifying Similarities and Differences


Marzano Chapter 2
Identifying Similarities and Differences

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter 2 dealt with the idea of similarities and differences and the importance of it in the classroom.  The text states we can draw generalizations of the theories and research.  The first being enhance student’s understanding and the ability to use knowledge present students with guidance in identifying similarities and differences.  Then ask students to identify similarities and differences independently.  The third generalization is to represent similarities and differences in a graphic or symbolic way.  The text talks about activities that are teacher directed and some that are student directed.  They all have highly significant effects on student learning.  Marzano aslos speaks about the use of graphic organizers and their effects on student learning.  The text also discusses ideas such as comparing, using metaphors, and analogies. 

Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
            In “The Art and Science of Teaching” another book by Marzano, he talks about the importance of graphic organizers and how it helps represent information.  Graphic organizers are an awesome way of representing similarities and differences of new information encountered by students.  Marzano calls in a critical input experience.  Students have to understand the information enough to know the characteristics and how they may be similar and different.  Then they have to represent that in some sort of graphic way.   Teachers can use graphic organizers in different ways.  They work as a class on identifying similarities and differences on a certain topic or they can be used in isolation by individual students or groups of students.  The more detailed the graphic organizer the more information the students will learn and retain. 

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests. 
            Identifying similarities and differences is a key component of any science classroom.  It is done on almost a daily basis whether it is comparing planets in an Astronomy lesson or finding out the differences in chemical compound in a Chemistry class.  With so many different ideas and topics in science students need to find away to graphically represent information or by the use of metaphors and analogies.  I personally love the idea of graphic organizers.  They take a lot of information and break it down into smaller and more retainable sections.  It allows students to think about characteristics of a topic and critically think about what make them different or similar.  For students to use a graphic organizer, metaphor, or analogy they first have to understand the subject or the information encountered.  When I start teaching, all these items will be of great use to me in a classroom.  It breaks such a vast topic in pieces to allow learning to take place.  

4 comments:

  1. I really like your passion towards graphic organizers. They are extremely useful in a science classroom as you mentioned. Also, I think it's great that you as teacher are so passionate about them because that will in turn make students passionate about them. Great ideas on that. I like the way you think!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you that the strategy of identifying similarities and differences is used almost every day in the science classroom. Graphic organizers are a great way to help the students compare and contrast concepts. I like how you also mentioned the importance of learning to take place. I can tell that you want to, and will, ensure that every student understands the material being presented and are successful.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Agree with evertything you said. Especially the part about breaking topics down to the details to really see what makes big ideas similar or different. I do worry though that they could get too broad or specific and lose some of their effectiveness due to the vast amount of information.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I appreciate all the feedback you are giving here. Being passionate is an important part of helping students become more passionate! Also, I agree that graphic organizers are helpful tools that make difficult material easier to understand.

    Dr. C.

    ReplyDelete