Marzano Strategy 9: Generating and Testing Hypothesis
Part 1
This chapter dealt with research and practice of generating and testing hypothesis. The process of generating and testing a hypothesis involves the application of knowledge. It is something that we do naturally. Hypothesis generation and testing can be approached in a more inductive and deductive manner. Deductive thinking is the process of using a general rule to make a prediction about a future action or event. Inductive thinking is the process of drawing a new conclusion based on information we know or are presented with. Teachers should also ask students to clearly explain their hypothesis and their conclusion. Students should carefully explain, usually in writing, the principles they are working from, the hypothesis they generate, and why the hypothesis makes good sense. The approach of simply asking them to explain their ideas in writing helps students deepen their understanding of the principles they are applying. There are six types of tasks they help students in generating hypothesis and testing. They are systems analysis, problem solving, historical investigation, invention, experimental inquiry, and decision making.
Part 2
In the Art and Science of Teaching, Chapter 4 deals completely with this topic. Marzano talks about action steps in generating hypothesis. Step one is to teacher students about effective support then engage students in experimental inquiry tasks. Next is to engage students in problem solving tasks then engage students in decision making tasks. Then ask students to participate in investigation tasks that make them generate and test hypotheses. Lastly have students design their own tasks and then consider how the extent to which cooperative learning structures will be used. Marzano also says teachers should examine their thinking regarding knowledge being learned which stimulates major changes in their understanding.
Part 3
In science hypothesis generation and testing is vastly important. Students often engage in lab experiments where students need to generate a hypothesis before and experiment and then test it. They also need to explain why they think their hypothesis is good and why they chose it. During my clinical I haven’t really seen this take place. They have been participating in a chemistry unit where students cannot really conduct labs or experiments in the eighth grade. In my classroom, I want to have students generate and test hypothesis often. Even if you cannot conduct labs you can give students scenarios and have them generate a hypothesis on how best to solve a problem and the steps they will take to test it. I could do this when it relates to a topic I am teaching or randomly take a day and allow them to do the scenario. Either it benefits the students in decision making and problem solving skills that will come in handy later on in school and life.
Ashley's Clinical Blog
Monday, November 15, 2010
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Marzano Chapter 10: Cues, Questions, and Advanced Organizers
Marzano 10: Cues, Questions, and Advance Organizers
Part 1
This chapter dealt with the strategy of cues, questions, and advance organizers. Cues and questions is a classroom strategy the teacher uses to help students use what they already know about a topic. Cues involve hints on what students are about to experiences. Questions are similar in that a teacher can ask questions to recall information about a topic before moving on to another or going more in depth to a topic. Cueing and questioning are the heart of classroom practice. Cues and questions should focus on the important information about a topic. Higher level questions produce deeper learning than the lower level questions. Teachers should also wait briefly before accepting responses from students. Research shows that it has an effect of increasing the depth of students’ answers. There are different types of questions a teacher can ask. The chapter also deals with advance organizers. Advance organizers are just another way to access students’ background knowledge. Advance organizers like cues and questioning should focus on important information and higher level organizers produces deeper learning. Advance organizers are most useful that is not well organized. Also different types of advance organizers produce different kinds of results.
Part 2
In the Art and Science of Teaching, Marzano says in chapter 2 that cues and questions are a way to preview new information. He says that with cues teachers can provide a direct link between old content and new content. Marzano also talks about questioning. One of the best kinds of questions is inferential questions. This type of question makes students elaborate on information they have experienced. The best strategy is called elaborative interrogation. This type of questions as the basic set up of “Why would that be true?” This type of question can greatly affect student comprehension.
Part 3
I believe cues and questioning is what teaching is all about. During a normal most of your day is asking questions and previewing new ideas. I believe the questions are important. Not only just asking them but asking the right kinds of questions at the right time. There are times to ask yes or no questions or questions with a direct answer. However, sometimes students need to be challenged with higher level questions to deepen their thought process and their learning. In my clinical, the teacher asks different types of questions. She often asks simple questions with a simple answer but sometimes she makes the students think with questions like, “What would happen to a chemical reaction if we changed this variable?” It makes the students think outside the box a little more. When I have thought the class, I caught myself giving cues and asking questions. We getting ready to play a game and I previewed before we even got to the game. It got the students excited. During the game, I asked questions about ionic compounds and why certain elements couldn’t make a compound. I noticed most of the question I asked was not exactly simple questions. They often made the students think about the answer before answering.
Monday, November 1, 2010
Marzano Cooperative Learning
Cooperative Learning
Part 1
Cooperative learning has five elements. The first is positive interdependence. This is the feeling of sink or swim together. The second element is face to face promotive interaction. This basically is a fancy way of saying they help each other to learn and then applauding success and effort. The third element is individual and group accountability. This element gives each member of the group accountability for their work but they are also accountable for their group work. This means that students should motivate the other students to work well in the group. The fourth element is interpersonal and group skills are acquired and tested. This leads to better communication skills, trust, leadership skills, decision-making skills, and learning how to deal with conflict. The last element is group processing. This element just means to determine how to reflect on how well the team is functioning and also how to make it better. Cooperative groups should not be based on ability except for some situations. They should also be relatively small groups and groups should not be overused in a classroom.
Part 2
In the Art and Science of Teaching, Marzano says in chapter 2 that there are different kinds of group work or cooperative learning groups. One kind of groups work is reciprocal teaching. This is a strategy means one student in a group becomes an expert on a subject and then raises questions that the group discusses. It challenges students to not only learn the content but propose questions. It requires a higher level of thinking. He also discusses the jigsaw strategy. In this students are put in groups and each given a topic to become experts on. Then the students teach their group about what they learned. There are many different kinds of cooperative learning activities for students to partake in. This strategy allows the teacher to cover a larger amount of content. It also makes the students learn the information to be able to relay the information to other students.
Part 3
Cooperative learning is a great strategy to use in a classroom. It can be done in a lab or used in other activities within the classroom. In my clinical the teacher recently used cooperative groups to help her students prepare for a chapter exam. She gave them a sample exam and put them in groups. They were to work together to get the answers. She told them if your partner has trouble with a problem and you understand it then you need to explain how you did that problem. The students responded very well to this activity. She put the students in group by them drawing a shape out of a box and the person that matches your shape was your partner. That way the students were randomly matched.
Monday, October 11, 2010
Marzano Chapter 4 - Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition
Marzano Chapter 4
Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 4 of Marzano discussed the topics of reinforcing effort and providing recognition. Research behind reinforcing effort says that people tend to believe success at a task has 4 causes. These causes are ability, effort, other people, and luck. Three of these beliefs can inhibit achievement. Two generalizations can be drawn from the research. The first is not all students realize the importance of effort. Students do not see that when a good amount of effort is given the end result is enhanced achievement on their work. Research indicates there is a direct relationship between effort and achievement. The second generalization is students can change their beliefs on effort. This means students can learn that effort pays off in the end and adapt to this new information. In the classroom, teachers should teach about effort and keep track of effort and achievement. Chapter 4 also discusses the topic of providing recognition. Other words to describe this topic are “praise” or “reward.” Rewards do not always have a negative effect on intrinsic motivation. Rewards are also more effective when it is dependent on the success of some standard of performance. The research on providing recognition also says that symbolic recognition can be more effective than tangible rewards. Teachers should personalize recognition and use concrete symbols of recognition such has stickers, awards, coupons, and treats. The use of rewards and providing recognition not only enhances achievement but stimulates motivation to do well
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
In “The Art and Science of Teaching,” Marzano also discusses both effort and recognition. He goes a little bit further than just talking about a direct link between effort and achievement. He says students can see their own effort and achievement but they can also see a direct link between effort and the amount of information learned and retained. He said formative assessment aids in this idea because students can observe their learning over time. Marzano also discusses the ideas of extrinsic awards and intrinsic motivation. They are often defined has opposites of one another. Extrinsic rewards are external like money or candy while intrinsic motivated behaviors are those that there are no rewards than the activity itself. However, one can lead to the other.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
I believe both of these ideas are important in a classroom. Students need to understand that the amount of effort put into a project or homework will lead to a higher level of achievement. In my clinical I have noticed that the teacher often tells the students you need to try harder and study. She often tries to get them to see that effort pays off. She also gives quite a bit of extrinsic rewards. They were playing Element Bingo and she gave out candy, erasers, and notebooks. The students had fun and had no idea that they were studying for their element quiz that was coming up. The students put an effort into the game but they also put effort into studying at the same time. The teacher also gives concrete symbolic rewards as well. She puts stickers on perfect scores and writes notes on their papers. I am learning a lot of great ideas to use when I teach. The students really seem to respond well to the extrinsic motivational techniques.
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Marzano Chapter 5
Marzano Chapter 5
Homework and Practice
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 5 of Marzano deals with the concepts of homework and practice. Homework is such a huge part of any education system in the United States. It becomes part of every student’s life. Four generalizations can be drawn about homework. The first being that homework should vary by grade. There has been controversy over whether homework is beneficial to elementary age students. Research indicates students gained more percentile points in grades 10-12 and 7-9 then in grades 4-6. The second generalization is parent involvement in homework should be as little as possible. Parent involvement with homework can have little to no positive effects. The third generalization is the purpose of homework should be explained and identified. Not all homework is the same and serves the same purpose. There are two common purposes to homework: practice and preparation or elaboration. The last generalization of homework is if homework is assigned it should be commented on. Teachers should establish communication and policy regarding homework and vary the feedback given to the homework. The second part of the chapter dealt with the idea of practice. The research states that to master a new skill requires a good amount of focused practice. Students should also adapt and shape what they have learned. Teachers should design practice assignments that focus on specific elements of a complex skill or process and plan time to do it.
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
In “The Art and Science of Teaching,” Marzano says homework relates to the theory of practice. Homework is meant to practice concepts and deepen knowledge about a topic. Homework extends learning beyond the school day and allows more time to practice. Marzano also discussed the time spent on homework should vary by grade level. The recommend amount of time spent on homework should be 10 minutes per night per grade level. This means a 1st grader should have 10 minutes of homework and a 5th grader should have 50 minutes of homework. For high school students they should have 30 to 60 minutes of homework per subject per night. Research also says homework should not become inordinate and should be coordinated between teachers. Marzano also points out that time spent on homework is almost meaningless. It is more important to have well-structured homework and have clear purpose then to have huge amounts of poorly structured homework.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
Homework was always a huge part of my education. Thinking back on it, it seems the homework was mostly the practice we never did in the class. In junior high and high school I had huge amounts of homework. I would easily spend 4-5 hours on homework some nights. My teachers never coordinated on what homework they were assigning or anything like that. When I teach I do not want to assign huge amounts of homework that serves no purpose. I want my homework to have a good rationale behind it. I also want to work with other teachers to make sure students do not get overloaded with too much homework. Too much homework can cause more harm than good. For example if students have a huge Math or English test I will not assign homework or not a lot of homework. Students need a chance to do well in their classes and if that means cutting back homework sometimes then so be it.
Sunday, September 26, 2010
Chapter 6: Nonlinguistic Representation
Chapter 6
Nonlinguistic Representations
Part 1: Summary
Marzano says that there are two systems for of representation – linguistic and nonlinguistic. He says that the use of both in the classroom can lead to students being able to think about and recall knowledge. Research has shown that the main way teacher’s present knowledge in the classroom in linguistic meaning that it is either talking about something or reading. Nonlinguistic representations are not used as much. Marzano states that nonlinguistic representation should elaborate on knowledge. The process of generating nonlinguistic representations engages students in elaborative thinking. Marzano goes on to give examples such as graphic organizers, physical models, mental pictures, drawing pictures, and engaging in kinesthetic activity.
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
In “The Art and Science of Teaching,” Marzano says that the linguistic aspect of information is something that can be read or talked about. The nonlinguistic aspect is the mental images or pictures associated with what is being talked or read about. Marzano then goes on to give examples similar to the ones given above. He also goes further and gives another form of nonlinguistic representation that is often overlooked. The mnemonic device is a strategy to help students memorize material such as facts or lists. Marzano points out that mnemonic devices are not lower order in thinking but are high level thought processes. He says effective memory techniques should not only recall information but also the understanding of the information.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
Nonlinguistic representation is something I will try to incorporate in my lessons as often as possible. I think by using both linguistic and nonlinguistic representation in the classroom in beneficial to all students. You meet the needs to students who learn differently and also help reinforce information. For example, when teaching a lesson on a body system, have the students write what the organ does and then label that organ on a picture. This uses both ways of representing knowledge. During one of my clinicals, the teacher actually had the students acting out different life cycles. Each group had a different cycle and each member had their part. Everyone learned their part and they presented their cycle to the rest of the class. This is another example of nonlinguistic representation.
Chapter 3: Summarizing and Notetaking
Marzano Chapter 3
Summarizing and Note Taking
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 2 of Marzano dealt with summarizing and note taking. Marzano discussed the importance of summarizing and note taking in the classroom. He talked about how to effectively summarize and how students must analyze information and have a deep level of thought to know what information is important to keep, delete, or substitute. Marzano discussed a “Rule Based” strategy for summarizing in the classroom. He says to delete trivial material, delete redundant material, substitute words for lists, and select a topic sentence. The chapter also looks into different strategies for summarizing. Marzano discusses narrative frames, topic-restriction-illustration frame, and other useful strategies. The second part of the chapter deals with research on note taking. Marzano discusses that verbatim note taking is the least effective way of taking notes. Students do not synthesize the information because they are focused on writing. Notes should also be a work in progress. This means teachers should have students edit, rewrite, and add to the notes. Notes should also be used as a study guide for tests and the more notes the better.
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
Marzano makes a many key points about summarizing and note taking in this chapter. He discussed summarizing more so than note taking. In an article in Eric Digest, Jeff Beecher, discusses that the act of note taking its self does little enhance recall. Research says that the reviewing of notes makes results in superior recall. The research also discussed the role of the teacher in note taking. They say that synthesis of material relates to the presentation of material. They suggest prepared notes in some instances to let the students know what to focus on. I think this article gives a little more information than did Marzano. I think reading this article gave a little more background and research on note taking.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests.
Summarizing and note taking is important in any classroom. It provides students the opportunity to analyze information and allows learning to take place. I believe both topics are greatly used in any science classroom. I know in the past in my science classes I took in middle school and high school; I came out with a huge notebook full of notes. At the end it provided me with an outline of the class and it contained the most important information from the class. When I was in school my notes were what I studied for tests. In the future, students note taking will be an important part of the class. I plan on teaching students how to effectively take notes on a daily basis, so they know what was covered that day and they can use it to study for an exam. I also want to encourage students to add and edit their notes as well. This allows more knowledge to be acquired even when out of the classroom.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)