Monday, October 11, 2010

Marzano Chapter 4 - Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition


Marzano Chapter 4
Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter 4 of Marzano discussed the topics of reinforcing effort and providing recognition.  Research behind reinforcing effort says that people tend to believe success at a task has 4 causes.  These causes are ability, effort, other people, and luck.  Three of these beliefs can inhibit achievement.  Two generalizations can be drawn from the research.  The first is not all students realize the importance of effort.  Students do not see that when a good amount of effort is given the end result is enhanced achievement on their work.  Research indicates there is a direct relationship between effort and achievement.  The second generalization is students can change their beliefs on effort.  This means students can learn that effort pays off in the end and adapt to this new information.  In the classroom, teachers should teach about effort and keep track of effort and achievement.  Chapter 4 also discusses the topic of providing recognition.  Other words to describe this topic are “praise” or “reward.”  Rewards do not always have a negative effect on intrinsic motivation.  Rewards are also more effective when it is dependent on the success of some standard of performance.  The research on providing recognition also says that symbolic recognition can be more effective than tangible rewards.  Teachers should personalize recognition and use concrete symbols of recognition such has stickers, awards, coupons, and treats.  The use of rewards and providing recognition not only enhances achievement but stimulates motivation to do well   
 
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
            In “The Art and Science of Teaching,” Marzano also discusses both effort and recognition.  He goes a little bit further than just talking about a direct link between effort and achievement.  He says students can see their own effort and achievement but they can also see a direct link between effort and the amount of information learned and retained.  He said formative assessment aids in this idea because students can observe their learning over time.  Marzano also discusses the ideas of extrinsic awards and intrinsic motivation.  They are often defined has opposites of one another.  Extrinsic rewards are external like money or candy while intrinsic motivated behaviors are those that there are no rewards than the activity itself.  However, one can lead to the other.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
            I believe both of these ideas are important in a classroom.  Students need to understand that the amount of effort put into a project or homework will lead to a higher level of achievement.  In my clinical I have noticed that the teacher often tells the students you need to try harder and study.  She often tries to get them to see that effort pays off.  She also gives quite a bit of extrinsic rewards.  They were playing Element Bingo and she gave out candy, erasers, and notebooks.  The students had fun and had no idea that they were studying for their element quiz that was coming up.  The students put an effort into the game but they also put effort into studying at the same time.  The teacher also gives concrete symbolic rewards as well.  She puts stickers on perfect scores and writes notes on their papers.  I am learning a lot of great ideas to use when I teach.  The students really seem to respond well to the extrinsic motivational techniques.      

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Marzano Chapter 5


Marzano Chapter 5
Homework and Practice

Part 1: Summary
            Chapter 5 of Marzano deals with the concepts of homework and practice.  Homework is such a huge part of any education system in the United States.  It becomes part of every student’s life.  Four generalizations can be drawn about homework.  The first being that homework should vary by grade.  There has been controversy over whether homework is beneficial to elementary age students.  Research indicates students gained more percentile points in grades 10-12 and 7-9 then in grades 4-6.  The second generalization is parent involvement in homework should be as little as possible.  Parent involvement with homework can have little to no positive effects.  The third generalization is the purpose of homework should be explained and identified.  Not all homework is the same and serves the same purpose.  There are two common purposes to homework: practice and preparation or elaboration.  The last generalization of homework is if homework is assigned it should be commented on.  Teachers should establish communication and policy regarding homework and vary the feedback given to the homework.  The second part of the chapter dealt with the idea of practice.  The research states that to master a new skill requires a good amount of focused practice.  Students should also adapt and shape what they have learned.  Teachers should design practice assignments that focus on specific elements of a complex skill or process and plan time to do it.
 
Part 2: Connection of the reading to another reading in class
            In “The Art and Science of Teaching,” Marzano says homework relates to the theory of practice.  Homework is meant to practice concepts and deepen knowledge about a topic.  Homework extends learning beyond the school day and allows more time to practice.  Marzano also discussed the time spent on homework should vary by grade level.  The recommend amount of time spent on homework should be 10 minutes per night per grade level.  This means a 1st grader should have 10 minutes of homework and a 5th grader should have 50 minutes of homework.  For high school students they should have 30 to 60 minutes of homework per subject per night.  Research also says homework should not become inordinate and should be coordinated between teachers.  Marzano also points out that time spent on homework is almost meaningless.  It is more important to have well-structured homework and have clear purpose then to have huge amounts of poorly structured homework.   

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
            Homework was always a huge part of my education.  Thinking back on it, it seems the homework was mostly the practice we never did in the class.  In junior high and high school I had huge amounts of homework.  I would easily spend 4-5 hours on homework some nights.  My teachers never coordinated on what homework they were assigning or anything like that.  When I teach I do not want to assign huge amounts of homework that serves no purpose.  I want my homework to have a good rationale behind it.  I also want to work with other teachers to make sure students do not get overloaded with too much homework.  Too much homework can cause more harm than good.  For example if students have a huge Math or English test I will not assign homework or not a lot of homework.  Students need a chance to do well in their classes and if that means cutting back homework sometimes then so be it.